Class of 2003
| John Browder | 1954 | Basketball – Baseball – Track |
| Lisa Graeff-Simko | 1978 | Volleyball – Basketball – Cheerleading – Track |
| Dave Gray | 1969 | Basketball – Baseball – Track |
| Glenn Harter | Coach 1954-1960 | Basketball – Track |
| Randy O’Dell | 1981 | Football – Basketball – Baseball |
| Ron Puterbaugh | 1956 | Basketball – Baseball – Track |
Class of 2004
| Richard Graeff | Coach 1961-1979 | Basketball – Track |
| Robert D. Shahan | 1957 | Basketball – Track – Baseball – Cross Country |
| James L. Troutwine | 1969 | Basketball – Track |
Class of 2005
| Terry Norris | 1956 | Basketball – Baseball – Track – Cross Country |
| Duane Reynolds | 1945 | Basketball – Baseball |
Class of 2006
| Glenn R. Harshbarger | 1948 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Kelly Murray Jay | 1984 | Basketball – Softball |
| Martin Montgomery | Coach 1975-1988 | Varsity Football |
Class of 2007
| Donnie J. Baker | 1987 | Basketball – Baseball – Football |
| Gary L. Riegle | 1969 | Basketball – Track – Cross Country |
| Miriam A. Lockman | Coach 1952-1973 | Girls All Sports |
Class of 2008
| Steve Christ | 1969 | Basketball – Track and Field |
| Jeff Rademachir | 1976 | Cross Country – Track and Field |
| Frank Cheadle | 1971 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Eugene R. Cullers | Coach 1960-1967 | Basketball – Baseball – Track and Field |
Class of 2009
| Crayton Roll | 1923 | Football – Basketball – Track and Field |
| Dan Norris | 1960 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Kevin O’Dell | 1977 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Josh Payne | 1990 | Cross Country – Track and Field |
Class of 2010
| Daron Jay | 1994 | Football – Basketball – Baseball |
| Ronald Condon | 1951 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Donald Harshbarger | 1951 | Basketball – Baseball |
Class of 2011
| Carrie Flora Feitshans | 1983 | Volleyball – Basketball – Softball |
| Rick E. Ary | 1978 | Football – Baseball |
| Tom Troutwine | 1963 | Cross Country – Basketball – Track and Field |
Class of 2012
| Kenneth Sebring | 1976 | Basketball |
| Sarah Ann Moore Baker | 2001 | Softball |
| Tom Paulus | 1982 | Football |
Class of 2013
| Tyler Small | 1994 | Cross Country – Track |
| Mike Swank | 1976 | Basketball |
| Tara Zimmer | 2001 | Swimming |
Class of 2014
| Scott Troutwine | 1984 | Swimming |
| Eldean Shelley | 1952 | Basketball – Track and Field |
| Marvin L. Engle | 1957 | Basketball |
Class of 2015
| Steve Carroll | 1981 | Football |
| Ralph E. Harshbarger | 1949 | Basketball – Baseball |
| Jim Fourman | 1963 | Basketball – Track – Baseball |
Class of 2016
| Julie Miller Wolfe | 1989 | Volleyball – Softball – Basketball |
| Paul Shahan | 1961 | Basketball – Baseball – Track – Cross Country |
Class of 2017
| Brenda Denlinger Doehrel | 2006 | Volleyball – Basketball – Softball |
| Brooke Strayer Hoying | 2006 | Track – Cross Country – Basketball – Softball – Cheer |
| Rex B. Karns | 1956 | Basketball – Baseball |
Class of 2018
Ty Cates 2006 Football – Basketball
Jeremy Pemberton 1993 Basketball
Gene Rench 1948 Baseball – Basketball – Track
Class of 2019
Shawn Hein 1988 Football-Basketball-Baseball
Richard O’dell 1957 Cross Country-Basketball-Baseball-Track
John Stephens 1994 Basketball-Baseball